Compensation

Pay Equity Audit: Step-by-Step Guide for EU Pay Gap Reporting

A practical, step-by-step pay equity audit for EU employers: what pay to include, how to build categories of work of equal value, the seven Article 9 indicators with formulas and a worked example, raw vs adjusted gaps, the 5% joint pay assessment rule and how to budget remediation.

Also available in: EspañolCatalàFrançaisDeutschItalianoPortuguês

Overhead view of a team around a wooden table with laptops, tablets and phones showing percentage figures, notebooks and coffee cups

A pay equity audit is a structured review of your pay data that compares women and men doing the same work or work of equal value, measures the gaps and tests whether objective, gender-neutral criteria explain them. For EU employers it is also the dry run for the gender pay gap reporting required by the EU Pay Transparency Directive (2023/970): the same data, categories and formulas you use in the audit will end up in the report.

This guide walks through the audit step by step: which pay elements to include, how to build categories of workers with a gender-neutral job evaluation, the seven Article 9 indicators with formulas and a worked example, raw vs adjusted gaps, the 5% joint pay assessment rule, and how to budget and document remediation. It closes with TalentUp data on how often 2026 job ads signal pay equity work and a short map of existing national regimes.

Key takeaways

  • The audit must cover all pay: base salary plus every complementary or variable component, in cash or in kind.
  • Compare people in categories of work of equal value, built from skills, effort, responsibility and working conditions, not job titles.
  • Article 9 requires seven indicators, including mean and median gaps for base and variable pay and pay quartiles.
  • A gap of 5% or more in any category that is not justified and not remedied within six months triggers a joint pay assessment.
  • First reports are due by 7 June 2027 for employers with 150+ workers, once national law has transposed the Directive.
  • In TalentUp’s 2026 data, 14.5% of compensation and reward job ads mention pay equity, equal pay or gender pay gap work.

What a Pay Equity Audit Must Cover Under the EU Directive

The Directive does not use the word “audit”, but it sets the standard any audit must meet. Three definitions matter:

  • Pay is the ordinary basic or minimum wage or salary plus any other consideration, in cash or in kind, that a worker receives in respect of employment, called complementary or variable components (Article 3).
  • Pay level is gross annual pay and the corresponding gross hourly pay, so part-time and full-time workers can be compared.
  • Pay gap is the difference between the average pay levels of female and male workers, expressed as a percentage of the average pay level of male workers.

The audit’s job is to calculate these gaps, explain them with objective, gender-neutral criteria, and correct what cannot be explained. Under Article 18 the burden of proof shifts to the employer in pay discrimination claims, so undocumented decisions are a risk in themselves.

Who Reports When

The transposition deadline was 7 June 2026, and reporting duties apply through national laws once each member state has transposed the Directive. Check where your countries stand in our EU pay transparency law tracker.

Workers First report Frequency Indicators
250 or more By 7 June 2027 (covering 2026) Every year All seven (a–g)
150–249 By 7 June 2027 (covering 2026) Every three years All seven (a–g)
100–149 By 7 June 2031 Every three years All seven (a–g)
Under 100 Not required by the Directive Member states may require it National rules

Management must confirm the accuracy of the report after consulting workers’ representatives, who can access the methodology. Indicators (a) to (f) go to the national monitoring body; the gap by category (g) goes to all workers and their representatives. For the full list of obligations, see our complete HR guide to the Directive.

Step 1: Set the Scope and Collect Pay Data

Most audits undercount gaps because they start with base salary only. Pull from payroll and your HRIS, for every worker on the reference date and over the reference year:

  • Base pay: contractual salary or wage, plus fixed allowances.
  • Variable and complementary pay: bonuses, commissions, overtime, shift and night premiums, profit sharing, sign-on and retention payments, long-term incentives.
  • In-kind benefits: company car, housing, meal vouchers, health insurance, pension contributions above the statutory minimum, valued in money.
  • Context: job, level, job family, location, contract type, working time (FTE and hours), hire date, time in role, performance rating, leave periods (maternity, paternity, parental, carers’).
  • Sex, as recorded for HR purposes and processed under GDPR. Article 12 of the Directive limits use of this personal data to applying equal pay rules.

Convert everything to gross annual and gross hourly figures so part-timers are not mis-measured. Decide in advance how you treat leavers, joiners and long-term absences, and write it down: the same rules must apply next year.

Step 2: Define Categories of Workers and Work of Equal Value

This is the most consequential step. The Directive defines a category of workers as workers performing the same work or work of equal value, grouped by the employer in a non-arbitrary way using the criteria in Article 4(4).

Those criteria are skills, effort, responsibility and working conditions, plus other factors relevant to the job where appropriate. They must be applied in an objective, gender-neutral way, and soft skills must not be undervalued. In practice this means a gender-neutral job evaluation: a points-factor or leveling system that scores each role on the same factors.

Approach How categories are built Risk
Job title Same title = same category Misses equal-value comparisons across functions; easy to challenge
Job family + level E.g. “Finance, level 3” Better, but may still separate equal-value roles in different families
Job evaluation score bands Roles with similar points across skills, effort, responsibility and conditions grouped together, across functions Most defensible; requires a documented, gender-neutral method

A good test: if a female-dominated role (for example, HR specialist) and a male-dominated role (for example, IT support specialist) score similarly on all four criteria, they should sit in the same category. Document why each role is where it is, and involve workers’ representatives early: they will review the method anyway.

Categories that are too narrow (two or three people) produce volatile gaps; categories that are too broad hide gaps. Aim for groups that are large enough for stable statistics but still genuinely comparable.

Step 3: Calculate the Seven Article 9 Indicators

Article 9 lists the indicators employers must report. All gaps use men’s pay as the denominator:

Gap (%) = (pay of men − pay of women) ÷ pay of men × 100

# Indicator (Article 9(1)) How to calculate
a Gender pay gap Mean pay of men vs mean pay of women, whole workforce
b Gender pay gap in complementary or variable components Same formula, using variable and complementary pay only
c Median gender pay gap Median pay of men vs median pay of women
d Median gap in complementary or variable components Same, using variable and complementary pay only
e Proportion of women and men receiving variable pay Women with any variable pay ÷ all women; same for men
f Proportion of women and men in each pay quartile band Rank all workers by pay, split into four equal groups, % women and % men in each
g Gap by category of workers Mean gap per category, split into basic pay and variable components

National laws and guidance can fix details such as the reference period, whether variable pay gaps use recipients only or all workers, or how to annualise. Follow your national method once it is published; until then, choose one rule and apply it consistently.

Worked Example (Synthetic Data)

The figures below are invented for illustration, not TalentUp data. A company of 200 workers looks at one category, “Level 3 professionals” (finance analysts, HR specialists, marketing specialists and IT support specialists with similar job evaluation scores): 20 women and 25 men.

Indicator for the category Women Men Gap
Mean gross annual base pay (FTE) €46,000 €49,500 7.1%
Median gross annual base pay (FTE) €45,500 €48,000 5.2%
Mean variable pay (recipients) €3,200 €4,800 33.3%
Median variable pay (recipients) €3,000 €4,200 28.6%
Share receiving variable pay 60% (12 of 20) 80% (20 of 25) 20 points

The mean gap is (49,500 − 46,000) ÷ 49,500 = 7.1%, above the 5% threshold. The variable pay figures show a second problem: women are less likely to receive variable pay and receive less when they do, a pattern that often comes from eligibility rules, discretionary bonuses or targets not pro-rated for part-time work or leave (see our guide to variable compensation).

For the whole company, the pay quartiles show where women sit:

Pay quartile (50 workers each) Women Men
Lower 64% 36%
Lower middle 52% 48%
Upper middle 40% 60%
Upper 28% 72%

Women are 46% of the workforce but only 28% of the top quartile. Quartiles do not prove unequal pay for equal work, but they reveal vertical segregation, which is often where promotion and starting-salary practices need attention.

Maira Q., a DEI lead and LinkedIn Top Voice who writes on workplace inclusion, warns that audits limited to like-for-like comparisons can miss exactly this pattern:

Maira Q.DEI Lead and LinkedIn Top Voice

Men are more likely to occupy roles where money concentrates. […] Compensation follows authority. […] Equal pay audits tell us whether compensation is aligned within roles. They do not explain how income is distributed across the organisation.

February 2026 Read on LinkedIn →

Step 4: Raw vs Adjusted Gap: Explain What You Find

The figures above are raw (unadjusted) gaps. A raw gap can reflect legitimate differences, such as more men in roles with longer tenure, or it can reflect unequal treatment. The audit has to separate the two.

Raw gap Adjusted gap
What it compares Average or median pay of women vs men Pay of women vs men with the same legitimate characteristics
Controls None, or only the category Level, tenure in role, location, performance, working time, etc.
Used for Article 9 reporting, triggers the justification duty Explaining the gap and sizing remediation
Typical tool Averages and medians Multiple regression (often a log-salary model)

Regression analysis estimates pay as a function of legitimate factors plus a gender variable. The coefficient on gender is the unexplained gap; the rest of the raw gap is explained. In the example, a regression with time in role, work location and performance rating leaves an unexplained gap of 3.1%: 4.0 of the 7.1 points are explained.

Three cautions:

  • Only objective, gender-neutral factors count. Negotiation outcomes, “market pressure” without documented data, prior salary or managerial discretion are weak explanations; a factor that is itself biased (for example, performance ratings that systematically score part-timers lower) cannot justify a gap.
  • The Directive’s trigger is the reported gap. A joint pay assessment applies where the difference in average pay is at least 5% and the employer has not justified it with objective, gender-neutral criteria. The regression is your evidence for that justification, so keep the model, data and reasoning on file.
  • Small categories make regression unstable. Below roughly 30 people, review individual cases against the salary band and job evaluation instead.

Kasey Swithenbank, UK and Ireland retail director at Lush, pushed back on the idea that women’s negotiation explains the gap, and turned the question back on leaders:

Kasey SwithenbankUK&I Retail Director, Lush

But reducing a systemic economic imbalance to “women should just ask better” misses the point entirely. […] As leaders, the uncomfortable questions aren’t theoretical, they’re operational. Are we auditing pay annually and acting on it?

February 2026 Read on LinkedIn →

Look beyond the averages too: outliers, starting salaries by gender, promotion pay increases and pay after return from maternity, paternity, parental or carers’ leave. Gaps between levels can hide compression problems that the audit will surface (see pay compression).

Step 5: Remediate, Budget and Document

The 5% Rule and the Six-Month Window

Under Article 10, an employer must carry out a joint pay assessment with workers’ representatives when all three conditions are met:

  1. Pay reporting shows a difference in average pay of at least 5% between women and men in any category of workers.
  2. The employer has not justified the difference with objective, gender-neutral criteria.
  3. The employer has not remedied the unjustified difference within six months of submitting the report.

The joint pay assessment covers the share of women and men in each category, their average pay and variable pay, the differences and their reasons, the share of women and men who received a pay improvement after returning from maternity, paternity, parental or carers’ leave, measures to address unjustified differences and an evaluation of earlier measures. It must be shared with workers, their representatives and the monitoring body, and employers must act on it, including by reviewing their job evaluation and classification systems.

The practical lesson: run the audit before the reporting year closes, so corrections are already in payroll when the first report is filed.

How to Budget Remediation

Size the cost from the regression or band review, not from the headline gap:

  1. Identify individuals whose pay sits below what the model predicts for their profile, or below the band position their level and experience justify (see range penetration).
  2. Price the adjustment for each person, plus employer social security and pension costs, which vary by country.
  3. Fix the cause, not only the symptom: starting-salary rules, bonus eligibility, promotion increases, pro-rating for part-time work and leave.
  4. Phase if necessary, but document the timeline: the six-month window is short.

In the synthetic example, nine women sit on average €2,500 below their predicted pay. Raising them costs €22,500 in base pay, about 1.0% of the category’s base payroll, and brings the category’s raw mean gap from 7.1% to about 4.8%. The variable pay gap needs a separate fix in eligibility and target-setting rules.

Documentation and Privilege

Keep an audit file for each cycle: data extract and cleaning rules, job evaluation method and scores, category definitions, formulas, regression specifications and results, explanations accepted and rejected, remediation decisions, approvals and dates. This is what you will need if a worker, a workers’ representative, a labour inspectorate or an equality body asks for clarification, and what supports your defence when the burden of proof is on you.

Some employers commission the analysis through external legal counsel to protect exploratory work. Privilege rules differ widely between countries and often do not cover in-house lawyers, and the statutory report and joint pay assessment must be shared anyway, so treat privilege as a narrow tool for preliminary analysis, not a way to keep results confidential.

TalentUp Data: How Employers Signal Pay Equity in 2026

Pay equity audits need people to run them. One way to see how far employers have moved is to look at what they ask of their compensation and reward teams in job ads, and what they say about equal pay to candidates.

14.5%

of compensation and reward job ads mention pay equity, equal pay or gender pay gap work

13.2%

mention pay transparency rules or the EU Directive

28.7%

mention job evaluation, job architecture or grading

Under 0.2%

of all job ads state an equal pay commitment to candidates

Source: TalentUp job postings database, January–September 2026. Sample sizes in the methodology below.

Across about 1,440 compensation and reward job ads in 12 European countries, one in seven describes pay equity, equal pay analysis or gender pay gap reporting as part of the role, and more than one in four mentions job evaluation or job architecture, the backbone of Step 2. Typical wording: “perform analysis and reporting on the equal pay and gender gap situation”, “leading the data analysis for gender pay gap reporting” or “lead initiatives related to pay transparency and pay equity”.

Country Reward ads (n) Mention pay equity / equal pay / pay gap Mention pay transparency rules
Sweden 64 21.9% 40.6%
United Kingdom 224 19.6% 10.3%
Spain 241 19.5% 8.3%
Ireland 78 15.4% 25.6%
Italy 150 12.0% 12.7%
Portugal 95 11.6% 8.4%
Germany 123 11.4% 13.0%
France 175 9.7% 12.6%
Netherlands 168 8.9% 8.9%

Three patterns stand out:

  • Countries with long-standing reporting rules lead on pay equity work. Sweden (annual pay surveys, lönekartläggning), the UK (gender pay gap reporting since 2017) and Spain (pay register and pay audits) have the highest shares.
  • Sweden and Ireland lead on the Directive itself, with 40.6% and 25.6% of reward ads mentioning pay transparency rules.
  • Candidates rarely hear about it. In a separate random sample of about 26,800 job ads across all roles, only 48 (under 0.2%) state a commitment to equal pay or pay equity, and several of those repeat the same employer’s boilerplate.

In the same months of 2024, about 3% of reward ads mentioned pay transparency rules, against 13.2% in 2026. Treat the comparison as directional, since the mix of sources in our data changed between the two years.

Market Data as an Objective Criterion

Market data does not prove equal pay, but it supports objective criteria: if every pay decision starts from a documented benchmark for the role, level and location, gaps that remain are easier to spot and harder to attribute to negotiation or discretion.

Seniority HR Business Partner, France: median gross annual base salary
Junior €33,200
Mid-level €42,900
Senior €56,000

Source: TalentUp Salary Platform, France, Human Resources Business Partner, data retrieved 10 July 2026.

The roughly 70% spread between junior and senior medians shows how much legitimate variation exists within one job family when levels are defined properly. A 5% unexplained gap within one level is a different matter, and that is what the audit has to find. To balance external benchmarks with internal equity, see market salaries vs internal equity, our methodology and plans.

National Regimes Already in Place

Several countries already require pay gap reporting or audits, and their rules will be adapted as the Directive is transposed. For country-by-country detail, see salary transparency in Europe.

Country Current regime What it requires
Spain Royal Decree 902/2020 on equal pay A pay register (registro retributivo) for all employers, with averages and medians by sex and pay element; a pay audit (auditoría retributiva) with job evaluation for employers that must have an equality plan; a written justification where the mean or median gap is 25% or more in those companies
France Index de l’égalité professionnelle Employers with 50+ employees calculate and publish an annual score out of 100; below 75 points, corrective measures are required, which can include salary catch-up
United Kingdom Gender pay gap reporting (2017 Regulations) Employers with 250+ employees publish mean and median hourly gaps, mean and median bonus gaps, the share receiving a bonus and pay quartiles. The UK is not bound by the EU Directive
Germany Entgelttransparenzgesetz (2017) Individual right to pay information in establishments with 200+ employees; private employers with 500+ employees are called on to run internal pay audits

If you already report in one of these countries, the audit is not starting from zero, but the Directive adds variable pay indicators, categories of equal value, the 5% threshold and joint pay assessments. For a preparation plan across countries, see how to build a compensation philosophy ready for the Directive and our pay transparency resource page.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

What is a pay equity audit?

A pay equity audit is a structured review of pay data that compares women and men doing the same work or work of equal value, measures the gaps and tests whether objective, gender-neutral criteria explain them. Its output is a set of gap figures, explanations and a remediation plan.

How do you conduct a pay equity audit?

Collect every pay element for all workers, group roles into categories of equal value using a gender-neutral job evaluation, calculate mean and median gaps for base and variable pay, then use regression to separate explained from unexplained gaps. Finish by correcting unjustified gaps, budgeting the cost and documenting every decision.

Which indicators does the EU Pay Transparency Directive require?

Article 9 lists seven: the mean and median gender pay gap, the mean and median gap in complementary or variable pay, the share of women and men receiving variable pay, the share of women and men in each pay quartile, and the gap by category of workers split into basic and variable pay.

When does the 5% threshold trigger a joint pay assessment?

When pay reporting shows a gap in average pay of at least 5% in any category of workers, the employer has not justified it with objective, gender-neutral criteria and has not remedied it within six months of submitting the report. The assessment is carried out with workers' representatives.

Who has to report pay gaps and when?

Once national laws transpose the Directive, employers with 250 or more workers report every year from 7 June 2027, those with 150 to 249 every three years from 7 June 2027, and those with 100 to 149 every three years from 7 June 2031. Member states can extend reporting to smaller employers.

What is the difference between the raw and the adjusted pay gap?

The raw gap compares average or median pay of women and men without controls. The adjusted gap is what remains after accounting for legitimate factors such as role, level, location or experience, and it is the part an employer has to explain or correct.

Share this article

LinkedIn X

Written by

Albert Mercadé Laborda

Marketing Manager

Albert leads marketing and growth at TalentUp, where he works at the intersection of HR, compensation & benefits and pay transparency. He turns TalentUp's salary data into practical guides that help HR and Total Rewards teams benchmark pay, build fair salary structures and get ready for the EU Pay Transparency Directive.

More articles by this author

Newsletter

Salary insights in your inbox, once a week

Benchmarks, pay transparency updates and practical guides for HR and compensation teams.

No spam. Unsubscribe at any time.