Handling candidate salary expectations under the EU Pay Transparency Directive comes down to one change of order: you share the pay range first, then you ask what the candidate expects. Once the Directive is transposed into national law, employers must give applicants the initial pay or its range before the negotiation starts and may not ask about their pay history; asking about expectations remains allowed.
That sounds simple, but it collides with long-standing habits. In TalentUp’s sample of 2026 job ads, 7.8% of ads in Germany ask candidates to send their “Gehaltsvorstellung” (salary expectations) with the application, and only about 7% of those ads give any salary figure themselves. The candidate names a number first, without information, which is exactly the situation Article 5 is designed to end.
This guide explains what the Directive changes, which wording is safe and which is risky, what research says about anchoring and the gender negotiation gap, what to do when expectations exceed your range, and gives recruiter scripts and an application-form checklist.
Key takeaways
- The Directive bans questions about pay history, not about salary expectations; the risk lies in asking for expectations before sharing any pay information.
- Give the initial pay or range in the ad or before the interview, then ask where the candidate sees themselves within it.
- In TalentUp’s 2026 sample, 7.8% of German job ads and 2.0% of Austrian ads ask for salary expectations; elsewhere in Europe it is under 0.5%.
- When expectations exceed the range, re-level, explain total rewards, consider a sign-on bonus or decline, but never improvise a base salary you cannot justify.
What the Directive Changes for Salary Expectations
Directive (EU) 2023/970 had to be transposed by 7 June 2026, but it reaches employers only through national laws, and many member states are still working on theirs (see where each country stands). Once transposed, Article 5 sets three recruitment rules:
| Article 5 rule |
What it says |
What it means for salary expectations |
| Right to pay information (5.1) |
Applicants have the right to receive the initial pay or its range, based on objective, gender-neutral criteria, plus any relevant collective agreement provisions |
The candidate should know your range before you discuss their number |
| Timing (5.1) |
Provided so as to ensure an informed and transparent negotiation on pay, such as in the job ad, prior to the job interview or otherwise |
Asking for expectations at application stage, with no range given, sits badly with this purpose |
| Pay history ban (5.2) |
An employer shall not ask applicants about their pay history in current or previous employment |
“What do you earn now?” and “What was your last salary?” are out |
| Neutral recruitment (5.3) |
Job vacancy notices and titles must be gender-neutral, and recruitment non-discriminatory |
Screening questions and forms are part of the recruitment process |
Two further rules matter after the offer. New hires gain the right to request information on average pay levels, by sex, for workers doing the same work or work of equal value (Article 7), and in an equal pay dispute the burden of proof shifts to the employer (Article 18). An offer anchored on what the candidate demanded, rather than on documented criteria, is hard to defend later.
National laws can be stricter. Italy’s Legislative Decree No. 96/2026 requires the initial pay or band in the job advertisement itself, and Poland’s Labour Code amendment, in force since 24 December 2025, already applies the range and pay history rules to recruitment. Austria has required job ads to state the minimum pay since 2011. For how this plays out in job ads, see our pay transparency job posting playbook.
The pay history ban is not new outside Europe. California, Massachusetts and New York, among other US states, already prohibit asking about salary history, which has produced the research discussed below.
Can You Still Ask “What Are Your Salary Expectations?”
Yes. Law-firm guidance from BDO and Freshfields agrees that the Directive does not prohibit the salary expectations question. Freshfields adds a warning: if an applicant states expectations before receiving the pay information, that could be seen as bargaining starting without the required transparency. The difference between a safe and a risky question is mostly timing and framing:
| Wording |
Risk |
Why |
| “The range for this role is €52,000–€58,000 gross per year. Where do you see yourself within it, and why?” |
Low |
Range first; the answer links to role criteria |
| “Does this range work for you?” |
Low |
Confirms fit without asking for a number |
| “What are your salary expectations?” (after the range has been shared) |
Low to moderate |
Allowed; better if you refer to the range |
| “Please include your salary expectations with your application” (no range in the ad) |
Moderate |
The candidate names a number before receiving pay information |
| “What is your current total package, including bonus?” |
High |
A pay history question in disguise |
| “Send me a payslip so we can make you an offer” |
High |
Pay history, and it makes the old salary the anchor |
| “We’ll match your current salary plus 10%” |
High |
The offer is based on pay history, not on the role |
National rules differ on details, so check the transposing law in each country where you hire and train recruiters, agencies and hiring managers on the same script.
What 2026 Job Ads Show: TalentUp Data
7.8%
of job ads in Germany ask for salary expectations
~7%
of those German ads state any salary figure
70%
of Austrian ads asking for expectations do state a salary
<0.5%
in Spain, France, Italy, the Netherlands, the UK and other markets
Source: TalentUp job postings database, January–September 2026. Random samples, recruitment agencies excluded; see methodology below.
We searched the text of about 20,500 job ads from eleven European countries for requests such as “salary expectations”, “Gehaltsvorstellung”, “pretensiones salariales”, “prétentions salariales” or “RAL attuale”, and compared them with the share of ads that state a salary.
| Country |
Ads asking for salary expectations |
Ads stating a salary |
Askers that state a salary |
| Germany |
7.8% |
20.1% |
~7% |
| Austria |
2.0% |
59.7% |
~70% |
| United Kingdom |
0.3% |
56.3% |
n/a (too few) |
| Spain |
0.2% |
21.7% |
n/a |
| Italy |
0.2% |
17.7% |
n/a |
| Netherlands |
0.2% |
49.2% |
n/a |
| Portugal |
0.2% |
11.9% |
n/a |
| Ireland |
0.1% |
21.3% |
n/a |
| Belgium |
0.1% |
14.4% |
n/a |
| France |
0.0% |
23.2% |
n/a |
| Poland |
0.0% |
34.4% |
n/a |
Three findings stand out:
- Asking for expectations in the ad is a German-speaking habit. The typical German ad ends with “send us your application, stating your earliest start date and your salary expectations”. In Germany, ads that ask for expectations are three times less likely to state a salary (about 7%) than ads that do not (about 21%).
- Austria shows the alternative. Because Austrian law already requires the minimum pay in the ad, most Austrian ads that ask for a “Gehaltsvorstellung” have already given a figure, so the candidate answers with information.
- Pay history requests almost never appear in writing. We found only two such requests in the whole sample (UK and Belgium). That does not mean the question has gone: it usually lives in application forms, screening calls and agency scripts, which ad text cannot show.
Why the Order Matters: Anchoring and the Gender Gap
Whoever names a number first sets the anchor for the rest of the negotiation. When the employer asks for expectations without giving a range, the candidate has to guess, and the guess usually rests on their current salary. That carries past pay gaps into the new job, which is why the Directive bans pay history questions.
Two peer-reviewed studies show why this matters:
- Explicit negotiability closes the gender gap in negotiating. In a natural field experiment with nearly 2,500 job seekers, Leibbrandt and List (2015, Management Science) found that when job ads did not say wages were negotiable, men were more likely than women to negotiate; when the ad stated explicitly that wages were negotiable, the difference disappeared. Ambiguity about how pay is set favours those who are most comfortable negotiating.
- Salary history bans raised pay for job changers, especially women. Bessen, Denk and Meng (Journal of Economic Inequality) studied US salary history bans and found that employers posted pay in job ads more often after the bans, and that job-changing women and non-white workers gained more than other job changers, according to the authors’ summary.
Laura Kray, Professor of Leadership at UC Berkeley’s Haas School of Business, adds an important nuance: her research suggests the problem today is less that women do not ask, and more how employers respond when they do.
Laura KrayProfessor of Leadership, UC Berkeley Haas School of Business
Excited to share new research challenging the notion that the gender pay gap is due to women not negotiating their salaries. In fact, we find that professional women negotiate more than men, but women get told no more often.
The practical lesson: share the range, say how pay within it is decided, and say that it is negotiable within those criteria. Candidates who are reluctant to negotiate then start from the same information as those who are not.
When Expectations Exceed Your Range
A transparent range does not stop candidates asking for more. It does mean every exception is visible. Work through these options in order:
| Option |
When it fits |
Watch out for |
| Re-level the role |
The candidate genuinely meets the criteria of the next level (scope, experience, skills) |
Document the evidence; if you hire one person at a higher level, others doing the same work may ask for the same |
| Move within the range |
The candidate has more of the experience the range rewards |
Check range penetration against current employees with similar profiles |
| Explain total rewards |
The gap is small and your bonus, pension or benefits are strong |
Show each element separately so the comparison is honest |
| One-off sign-on bonus |
The gap comes from the move itself, for example a forfeited bonus |
Keep it outside base pay and set clear clawback terms; see our sign-on bonus guide |
| Review the range |
Several strong candidates reject the same range |
Re-benchmark with current market data; a range below market is a structural problem, not a negotiation |
| Decline politely |
None of the above applies |
Say so early and clearly; it saves time on both sides |
What you should not do is pay one candidate above the range “because they asked”. Once the Directive is transposed, colleagues doing the same work can request average pay information, and an unexplained outlier becomes evidence of a gap.
Keep Offers Consistent: Equal Pay and Internal Equity
The Directive’s core principle is equal pay for equal work or work of equal value. Each offer becomes a data point in that comparison, so treat offers as part of your pay structure, not as one-off deals:
- Decide the offer from criteria, not from the ask. Place the candidate in the range using the same documented factors you use for current employees: experience relevant to the role, skills, scope.
- Compare with the team before sending it. If the new hire would earn more than colleagues doing the same work with similar experience, either justify the difference or review the colleagues’ pay. Our guide on internal equity vs external competitiveness explains how to balance both.
- Record the reasons. A short note on why the offer sits where it does is the cheapest defence if the burden of proof ever shifts to you.
- Use the same criteria for everyone. Two candidates with similar profiles should get similar offers, whatever they asked for.
Recruiter Scripts for the Salary Conversation
Recruiters need words they can use on the phone. These scripts follow the order range first, expectations second, criteria always:
Opening the topic (first screening call):
“Before we go further, I want to share the pay for this role: the range is €52,000 to €58,000 gross per year, plus an annual bonus of up to 8%. Does that work for you?”
Asking about expectations:
“Within that range, where do you see yourself, and which parts of your experience support that?”
When the candidate asks for more than the maximum:
“Thank you for being clear. The maximum for this level is €58,000. Let me check whether your experience fits the next level; if it doesn’t, I’d rather tell you now than waste your time.”
When the candidate volunteers their current salary:
“Thanks, but we don’t use current or previous pay to set offers. Our offer depends on the role and the criteria we use for everyone in it.”
When the candidate asks how the offer was decided:
“Your offer sits in the upper half of the range because of your experience leading a team, which is one of the criteria for this level.”
For a fuller list of what recruiters can and cannot ask, see the interview table in our job posting playbook.
Ad text is only part of the picture: the riskiest questions usually sit in application forms, ATS screening questions and agency scripts. Review them all:
- Remove “current salary” fields from application forms, ATS templates and agency briefing documents.
- Show the range before any expectations field. If your form asks for expected salary, the job ad or the form itself must already show the range.
- Make the expectations field optional or phrase it as “Does the advertised range work for you?” (yes/no).
- Brief recruitment agencies in writing that they may not ask about pay history on your behalf.
- Train hiring managers, who are often the ones who ask “what are you on now?” in the interview.
- Delete pay history that candidates volunteer in CVs or emails from your evaluation notes.
- Use one script across countries, adjusted for stricter national rules where you hire.
- Log offer decisions with the criteria used and the position in the range.
- Review ranges when candidates repeatedly reject them, instead of negotiating case by case.
For the wider set of obligations, see the complete HR guide to the Directive and our guide to transparent salary job postings. To set ranges candidates will accept, start with the free pay transparency salary benchmark.
Sources
- TalentUp. Job postings database, random samples of about 20,500 postings from eleven European countries published January–September 2026, recruitment agencies excluded (see methodology above).
- European Union. Directive (EU) 2023/970 to strengthen the application of the principle of equal pay for equal work or work of equal value between men and women through pay transparency and enforcement mechanisms, Articles 5, 7 and 18. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2023/970/oj
- Leibbrandt, A. and List, J. A. (2015). Do Women Avoid Salary Negotiations? Evidence from a Large-Scale Natural Field Experiment. Management Science, 61(9), 2016–2024. NBER Working Paper 18511: https://www.nber.org/papers/w18511
- Bessen, J., Denk, E. and Meng, C. Perpetuating Wage Inequality: Evidence from Salary History Bans. Journal of Economic Inequality. DOI: 10.1007/s10888-023-09610-9. Summary: https://sites.bu.edu/tpri/2024/05/01/perpetuating-wage-inequality-evidence-from-salary-history-bans
- BDO Belgium. The Pay Transparency Directive: Frequently Asked Questions (2026). https://www.bdo.be/en-gb/insights/articles/2026/the-pay-transparency-directive-frequently-asked-questions
- Freshfields. Pay transparency revolution: applicants’ rights under the EU Pay Transparency Directive. https://www.freshfields.com/en/our-thinking/blogs/risk-and-compliance/pay-transparency-revolution-applicants-rights-under-the-eu-pay-transparency-dir-102me9f