The levels of pay transparency describe how much pay information an organization shares, and with whom: from closed pay, where only HR knows the numbers, to process transparency, internal salary ranges, ranges in job ads and, at the far end, fully open individual salaries. Most companies do not need to reach the top level. They need to choose the right level for their context, build the foundations for it and explain it well.
The choice is no longer entirely free in Europe. The EU Pay Transparency Directive (2023/970) sets a minimum level that applies as each member state transposes it into national law: pay criteria accessible to employees, the right to request pay information by gender, no pay secrecy clauses and pay ranges for candidates before the interview. Everything above that floor is a strategic choice.
This guide gives you a five-level maturity model, maps it against the Directive, shows where employers in ten European countries stand today with TalentUp job ad data, and ends with a decision table, a policy template and a communication plan for managers and employees.
Key takeaways
- Pay transparency has five levels: closed, process, internal ranges, ranges in job ads and open salaries. Each level needs the foundations of the one below.
- Once transposed, the EU Directive sets a floor at roughly level 2 plus pay information for candidates, and it bans pay secrecy clauses, so level 0 stops being an option.
- In TalentUp’s 2026 data, only the UK and the Netherlands publish pay in close to half of job ads or more; in half of the 10 countries analyzed, fewer than 1 in 4 ads state a salary.
- Choose your level by jurisdiction, size, pay-structure maturity and equity audit results, then write it down in a pay transparency policy and brief managers first.
The 5 Levels of Pay Transparency
Pay transparency is best seen as a ladder, not a switch. Each step shares more information with more people, and each step only works if the one below is solid: publishing ranges makes no sense if nobody can explain how pay is set within them.
| Level |
What you share |
Who sees it |
Prerequisites |
Typical for |
| 0. Closed pay |
Nothing beyond the employee’s own contract; pay discussions discouraged |
HR and senior leaders |
None |
Traditional organizations; not compatible with the Directive once transposed |
| 1. Process transparency |
Pay philosophy, how pay is set, criteria for raises, bonuses and promotions |
All employees |
Documented pay policy and criteria |
First step for most companies |
| 2. Internal ranges |
Salary range for each employee’s own role, then for all roles and levels |
All employees |
Job architecture, benchmarked salary bands, equity audit |
The practical baseline for EU employers |
| 3. Ranges in job ads |
Hiring range for each vacancy, published externally |
Candidates and the market |
Level 2 in place, ranges consistent with current pay |
Employers competing for talent; mandatory in some jurisdictions |
| 4. Open salaries |
Individual pay of every employee, often with the formula behind it |
All employees, sometimes the public |
Formula-based pay, very clean data, a culture of openness |
Small or mission-driven organizations |
Level 0: Closed Pay
Only HR and a few leaders know the numbers, employees are discouraged from comparing pay and contracts may include pay secrecy clauses. It feels safe, but it leaves employees to guess, and guesses tend to be worse than reality. Once the Directive is transposed, contractual terms that stop workers from disclosing their pay are not allowed, so in the EU level 0 has an expiry date.
Level 1: Process Transparency
You explain how pay is decided without publishing the numbers: your pay philosophy (lead, match or lag the market), the factors that determine pay, how performance links to raises and bonuses, and when reviews happen. This is the cheapest level to reach and the one that makes every other level credible.
Level 2: Internal Ranges
Employees see the salary range for their own role and level, and in a more advanced version the ranges of all roles, so they can see what the next step pays. This requires a job architecture (roles grouped into families and levels) and salary bands built from market data. Our guide to market salaries vs. internal equity explains how to balance both when you build them.
Level 3: Ranges in Job Ads
You publish the hiring range for each vacancy. This exposes your structure to candidates, competitors and, importantly, your own employees, who will compare the ad with their payslip. Our article on transparent salary job postings covers how to write the range, how wide it should be and the rules in the US and Canada.
Level 4: Open Salaries
Everyone can see what everyone earns. This works for a small number of organizations with formula-based pay and very consistent data. For most employers, it adds privacy and data-protection questions without much benefit over level 2 or 3 done well.
Types of Pay Transparency: Process, Outcome and Communication
You will also see pay transparency split into types rather than levels. Process transparency is about how pay is decided, outcome transparency about the actual figures (ranges or individual pay), and communication transparency about whether people may discuss pay freely. The five levels combine the three: level 1 is pure process transparency, levels 2 to 4 add progressively more outcome transparency, and the end of pay secrecy clauses is communication transparency.
What the EU Directive Sets as the Floor
The Directive does not ask any employer to publish individual salaries. It sets a minimum level of transparency that sits roughly at level 2, plus pay information for candidates. These obligations bind employers through national laws, once each member state transposes the Directive.
| Directive obligation |
Article |
Level it corresponds to |
| Candidates receive the initial pay or its range before the interview, in the vacancy notice or otherwise |
Art. 5 |
Level 3 (without necessarily publishing it in the ad) |
| Employers may not ask candidates about their pay history |
Art. 5 |
Process rule for hiring |
| Criteria used to determine pay, pay levels and pay progression are easily accessible to workers, objective and gender-neutral |
Art. 6 |
Level 1 (member states may exempt employers with fewer than 50 workers from the pay progression part) |
| Workers can request, in writing, their individual pay level and the average pay levels by sex for workers doing the same work or work of equal value; employers must answer within two months and inform workers of this right every year |
Art. 7 |
Close to level 2 |
| Workers cannot be prevented from disclosing their own pay; pay secrecy clauses are prohibited |
Art. 7 |
Ends level 0 |
| Gender pay gap reporting: 250+ workers annually from 7 June 2027; 150–249 every three years from 7 June 2027; 100–149 every three years from 7 June 2031 |
Art. 9 |
Reporting duty, independent of your level |
| Joint pay assessment if a gap of 5% or more in a worker category is not justified by objective, gender-neutral criteria and not remedied within six months |
Art. 10 |
Reporting duty |
Two further points change the risk calculation. In pay discrimination cases the burden of proof shifts to the employer, so a structure you cannot explain is a liability at any level. And since employees can request average pay by gender for their category anyway, keeping ranges secret protects less than it seems.
Laura Voinea, who brings more than 20 years of HR leadership to the German consultancy UPFLINX, argues that the real question is where transparency ends and legitimate confidentiality begins:
Laura VoineaStrategic HR & Talent Innovation, Start-Up & Leadership Coach, UPFLINX
The EU Pay Transparency Directive does not mean that every employee’s salary becomes public information. But it does raise expectations around access to information, objective pay criteria, comparable work and the explanation of pay differences. […] Because transparency works much better when everyone understands what can be shared, what must remain confidential, and why.
The transposition deadline was 7 June 2026, but implementation is uneven: as of September 2026, Euronews reported that only five member states (Italy, Slovakia, Malta, Lithuania and Greece) had transposed the Directive, and that Germany had delayed its law until early 2027. Check the national law in every country where you employ people, because it may go further than the Directive. For the full set of obligations, see our EU Pay Transparency Directive compliance guide and our overview of the 2026 EU pay transparency law and its timeline.
How Transparent Are Employers Today? TalentUp Data
Job ads are the most visible signal of an employer’s transparency level. We measured how many job postings in ten European countries state a salary in January–September 2026.
~58%
of job ads in the UK state a salary, the highest share in our sample
5 of 10
countries have fewer than 1 in 4 job ads with a salary
44%
of ads that state pay use a range rather than a single figure
Source: TalentUp job postings database, January–September 2026. Minimum estimates, see methodology below.
| Country |
Ads stating a salary, 2026 |
Transparency tier |
| United Kingdom |
~58% |
High |
| Netherlands |
~50% |
High |
| Poland |
~35% |
Medium |
| Spain |
~27% |
Medium |
| France |
~25% |
Medium |
| Germany |
~22% |
Medium |
| Ireland |
~21% |
Medium |
| Belgium |
~19% |
Low |
| Italy |
~17% |
Low |
| Portugal |
~11% |
Low |
Tiers: High = 40% or more of ads state a salary; Medium = 20–39%; Low = below 20%.
Three conclusions for choosing your level:
- Level 3 is still a differentiator in most of the EU. Outside the UK and the Netherlands, roughly three in four job ads or more do not state pay, so publishing a credible range still makes an ad stand out.
- Rules move the needle. Poland, where candidates must receive pay information before the first interview since December 2025, is the clear leader among EU markets after the Netherlands.
- When employers do share pay, a range is already the most common single format: at least 44% of ads with a salary use a range rather than a fixed figure, counting salaries written in the ad text as well as structured salary fields. A range is what the Directive asks employers to justify with objective criteria, so this is the format to prepare.
How to Choose Your Level of Pay Transparency
There is no universally right level. Five questions narrow it down quickly:
- Where do you employ people? In EU countries that have transposed the Directive, levels 0 and 1 alone are not enough. In some US states and Canadian provinces, ranges in job ads are mandatory.
- How big are you? The Directive’s reporting duties start at 100 workers, and member states may exempt employers below 50 from the pay progression criteria. Larger employers also have more comparisons to explain.
- How mature is your pay structure? Without a job architecture and benchmarked bands, you cannot publish ranges you can defend. Build them first; our guide to salary benchmarking for pay transparency compliance explains how.
- What does your equity audit show? If people in the same role are paid differently for reasons you cannot explain with objective, gender-neutral criteria, fix the gaps before you share more.
- How competitive is your hiring market? Where candidates expect ranges, and where few competitors publish them, level 3 can attract better-matched applicants.
Decision Table
| Your context |
Recommended level |
First step |
| EU employer, no job architecture, pay set case by case |
Level 1 now, level 2 within 12 months |
Document pay criteria and build job families and levels |
| EU employer with bands, but no recent equity audit |
Level 2 internally; level 3 after the audit |
Run a pay equity audit by role and gender and fix unexplained gaps |
| EU employer with benchmarked bands and a clean audit |
Level 3 |
Publish hiring ranges in job ads and brief managers before launch |
| Employer of 100+ workers in the EU |
At least level 2 |
Prepare gender pay gap reporting and a process for information requests |
| Fewer than 50 employees, simple roles |
Level 2, or level 4 if pay follows a formula |
Write down how pay is set; check whether national law exempts you from progression criteria |
| Hiring in US states or Canadian provinces with posting laws |
Level 3 for those roles |
Align the posted range with your internal bands for the same role |
| Multinational with mixed jurisdictions |
One global policy at level 2, level 3 where required or useful |
Set a common minimum and add local requirements country by country |
How to Write a Pay Transparency Policy
A pay transparency policy turns your chosen level into rules people can follow. Keep it short, specific and consistent with your national law. This outline works as a template:
- Purpose and scope. Why you share pay information, which entities, countries and employee groups the policy covers, and the transparency level you commit to.
- Pay philosophy. Your market position (lead, match or lag), the market data you use and how often it is refreshed.
- Job architecture. How roles are grouped into job families and levels, and how a role is assigned to a level.
- Pay ranges. How ranges are built, how wide they are, who approves them and when they are reviewed.
- How pay is set and progresses. Objective, gender-neutral criteria for starting pay, raises, promotions and bonuses, and the review calendar.
- What is shared, and with whom. For example: own range for all employees, all ranges on the intranet, hiring ranges in job ads, pay criteria in the handbook.
- Recruitment rules. Ranges given to candidates before the interview, no questions about pay history, gender-neutral job titles and ads.
- Employee information requests. How to ask for individual and gender-averaged pay information, who answers and within what deadline (two months under the Directive).
- Roles and responsibilities. What HR, managers and leadership each do, including who can approve pay outside the range.
- Data protection and confidentiality. How pay data is stored, who can access it and how individual data is protected when averages are shared.
- Pay gap reporting and remediation. For employers in scope: what you report, when, and how unexplained gaps are corrected.
- Review cycle and contact. When the policy is reviewed and where employees can take questions.
How to Communicate Pay Transparency to Managers and Employees
Most transparency projects that go wrong fail in communication, not in the data. Brief managers first, then employees, and only then candidates.
Managers First
- Give managers the ranges, the criteria and their team’s position in the ranges a few weeks before employees see anything.
- Train them on the questions they will get, including how to explain where someone sits in a range and what it takes to move.
- Tell them what they cannot say or ask, such as asking candidates about their pay history where the Directive applies.
- Set an escalation route for cases they cannot answer, such as an employee below the range.
Then Employees
Announce the change with a clear message covering what will be shared, why, how pay is decided and where to go with questions, and follow up with team sessions led by managers. Publish an internal FAQ and keep it updated with real questions.
| Employee question |
How to answer |
| “Why am I paid less than the job ad?” |
Explain the criteria that place pay in the range and, if the gap is not justified, the correction plan and timeline |
| “Why is my range lower than another team’s?” |
Show how roles are levelled and benchmarked against the market for that job family |
| “How do I move up in my range?” |
Link progression to the documented criteria: performance, skills and scope |
| “Can I see what my colleague earns?” |
State what the policy shares; under the Directive, employees can request average pay by gender for their category, not a colleague’s individual pay |
| “Can I tell others what I earn?” |
Yes; once the Directive is transposed, contract clauses that prevent this are not allowed |
UK reward consultant Rachael Dodic, founder of Horizon Reward & People Solutions, sums up what managers need to get across when employees start comparing pay:
Rachael DodicHR Reward Consultant, Founder, Horizon Reward & People Solutions
There can be valid reasons why two people doing the same role at the same level are paid differently. The important part is being able to explain why the difference exists. […] Pay equity isn’t about removing every difference. It’s about ensuring the differences that exist are fair, evidence-based and defensible.
Common Mistakes When Moving Up a Level
- Sharing numbers before auditing them. Publishing ranges that existing pay does not respect exposes gaps overnight.
- Skipping level 1. Ranges without criteria invite every employee to argue for the top of the band.
- Ranges too wide to mean anything. A range that doubles from minimum to maximum tells nobody anything and is hard to justify.
- Inconsistent answers from managers. One unprepared manager can undo months of preparation.
- Treating it as a one-off project. Ranges drift from the market quickly; review them at least once a year.
For a deeper look at what can go wrong, read Can Pay Transparency Backfire?, and for the country-by-country strategic picture see navigating salary transparency in Europe. If you need market data to build defensible ranges, start with the free pay transparency salary benchmark or see how TalentUp builds its salary data.
Sources